The Plastics Challenge: A Day Without Plastic?
Spend one day trying to live without any plastics. See how far you get.... (The other blog with student entries is at http://plasticschallengekatieroehlsection308.blogspot.com )
Tuesday, December 7, 2010
A day without plastic
Monday, December 6, 2010
Plastics Challenge
Walking to class from Mifflin Street would be longer and colder without the bike, but there is too much plastic on my bike for an attempt without them. Just as others have mentioned, even taking notes has its obstacles. Pens, pencils, and notebooks can all contain plastic elements. Instead of answering the note-taking dilemma, I intentionally chose a day with few classes that I don’t take notes in anyways. This goes to show that you can’t just pick any day for a challenge like this. What if you had an exam?! You couldn’t sit in a plastic seat if that’s the entire lecture hall had. After a morning lecture, lunch is in order.
Any take out or dine in would be difficult since plastic is one of the main components in food transport and storage. So, I walked back to the apartment to prepare some fresh food. Pasta from a paper box and fresh veggies would suffice for a plastic-less meal. This of course is omitting the transportation materials it took to get to my house, not to mention the cultivation of the wheat, production of the noodles, etc.
What to do with the rest of my day now? I couldn’t go outside anymore because shoes and winter clothes contain plastic accessories. Staying inside, I took a comfy seat on my papasan chair made of fabric and bamboo, and read some books for class. I tried to retain as much as I could without taking notes. After many hours of reading, I wanted a study break really badly. I would usually browse the internetz or go workout, but both are out of the question. And to think, even if I was able to posses a plastic free computer, the entire system of electricity and cable internet relies on plastic parts. Every single website relies on a server, which contains plastic bits. This blog would not survive without plastic. Ironic, eh? For dinner, I went back into the fridge and pulled out the pan I used to cook my pasta in, re-opened the sauce jar, and re-heated it on the stove. To continue to keep true to the challenge, dishes would have to be done the next day (woo hoo). With nothing more to do, I called it an early night in order to get up the next day and continue my plastic life.
I may not have been as dedicated as others were to this project but it did make me more aware of the staple that plastics have in my life. It reminded me of the lab work that I did this summer. While going through countless plastic tubes and pipette tips, I realize that the success and productivity of modern laboratories rely on plastics. Items are cheap enough to be thrown away and therefore can be used to keep contamination to a minimum. Smaller and smaller concentrations on the mass spectrometers can be read yielding more efficient pharmaceuticals. With the talk of BPA, it’s interesting to think that these plastics can take away AND give contamination– A true double edge sword.
Plastic is Fantastic!
Cheated and Still Failed
Just kidding.
I cheated and I still failed. Not only did I shower in my plastic shower curtain-lined bath tub the night before, I took the plastic dolphin from Florida off my keychain, and put coffee in my metal and glass French press the night before, too (I high-fived myself and then took it back, as one of my bags of coffee is made out of paper but it has a pointless window made of a plastic film).
Uh oh, we've got trouble. Every day I work at Memorial Library where I use a plastic computer, a plastic printer, a plastic coffee maker (could I be so self-centered as to deny my fellow librarians fresh coffee? No!), pens and mechanical pencils made of plastic, et cetera. I didn't want to get fired, so I worked as usual and thought about how big a role plastics play in my life, and how I wouldn't be able to go about my normal routine without them.
Each morning I use a plastic toothbrush with my toothpaste that is in a plastic casing, I put in my plastic contact lenses or wear my plastic-framed glasses in order to see the front of the classroom, and I use my plastic toaster and plastic-lined refrigerator for breakfast. In this day and age, many women wear some quantity of make-up, and I admit that I do (and I enjoy it). I have been trying to switch over to more natural/organic brands, but they still come packaged in loads of plastic. It's too bad there isn't a recycling program for empty cosmetics items!
I tried planning meals around the non-use of plastic, but I failed again. I thought I could use my glass storage containers to transport food to work and class, but they all have plastic lids. With my relatively hectic schedule, I forgot that I could have used the empty salsa, applesauce and spaghetti sauce containers of glass and aluminum my roommate and I have collected. I constantly wonder what sorts of gunk is leaching into my food and water. Yikes.
Alas, even my bedroom is overwhelmed by plastic materials. How could I possibly read "My Year of Meats" without the assistance of my ridiculously adorable IKEA reading lamp? Why do a lot of plastic things have to be so gosh darn adorable?
All in all, I continuously try to decrease my consumption and usage of plastic materials, because every time my wonderful roommate or I take out the recycling, I feel so guilty about its quantity.
If I didn't use plastic materials every day, I would never use my computer or cell phone, I would lay in bed all day and read or go outside and frolic and ask my boyfriend to cook meals for me with all of my plastic utensils, refrigerator, and storage containers. This sounds like a perfect vacation, but I couldn't do this forever.
Lastly, now that it is of a holiday-worthy temperature, I wear my bulky Columbia coat that has multiple kinds of plastics in it (along with my bulky but reliable boots) and I take the city bus that is comprised of all sorts of plastics. If I didn't do these things, I would either be frostbitten every day or never leave my lovely house.
These are a few of the thoughts I had of this day (more like week) of trying to not use plastics. Don't worry creatures of the Pacific Ocean, I will try as hard as I can to not add to your already gargantuan garbage patch!
-Melissa Flores, TA Tiffany Grade
Plastic is EVERYWHERE
Jolie Lizotte's Day Without Plastic (TA Tiffany)
On the morning of the my No Plastics Day I looked at all of the tags of the clean clothes I had with me at my parents house. I realized that all my pants and shirts were made with at least some rayon, polyester, or spandex, which all contain plastic. So I borrowed a shirt and pants from my mom that were made with 100% cotton. I wore underwear that was 100% cotton except for the elastic band. I chose not to take a shower that day since the shampoo & conditioner were in plastic bottles. Instead of brushing my teeth with a toothbrush and toothpaste, I rubbed my teeth with a non-plastic substitute: baking soda (which my parents store in a glass jar).
Luckily, since it was Thanksgiving all of the food I ate that day was made from scratch so I avoided the problem of food wrapped in plastic. However some of the ingredients my mom used to make the food came from plastic containers. such as the goat's milk and feta cheese. Also after the Thanksgiving meal most of the leftovers were put in plastic containers since we did not have any non-plastic alternatives. We used glass/ceramic dishes and silverware all day to avoid plastic.
I avoided using my phone for most of the day, although I made a exception to talk to my grandparents in Florida. I did not use the computer or television that day. Since it was a day that I had off from homework and my job I did not have to use my computer, but on most days this is really hard to do since most of our homework requires a computer and I have to use computers at work. While doing more electronically can be better for the environment because it reduces paper usage, it made me realize that most electronics are made with plastics, which are not environmentally safe.
I had my next encounter with plastic when I decided to go outside to walk my dog with my sister. In order to go outside I had to use plastic. My shoes have plastic in them and on the shoelaces. The zippers on my jacket were made with plastic. After experiencing some guilt about the necessity of plastic in order to experience nature in the cold, I decided to forgo not using plastic during my walk. My sister had to use a plastic leash and a harness containing plastic in order to get my dog ready to go for a walk.
At the end of the day when it began to get darker I realized that the light switches were all made from plastic. In order to have enough light in the kitchen to clean up from Thanksgiving dinner we had to turn on the lights. The light fixtures probably also contained plastic. Since all writing tools (ie pens and pencils) contain plastic I had to wait until the next day to write down my notes about my Day Without Plastics.
I think my family got a kick out of watching me go without plastics. They still used plastic (such as playing CDs in the living room CD player), but helped me avoid using it. My parents original suggestion was for me to spend the day in a tent in the backyard to avoid using plastic ... however we realized that would not have even worked since our tent is made with plastic. I imagine it would be very hard to find a tent these days made entirely from cloth. This day made me realize how surrounded we are by plastic. Even looking around my room right now I can see at least 60 objects made with plastic. Most of them I use everyday, such as my alarm clock, CD player, lamp, computer, clothes hangers, vitamin containers, etc. In order for our society to stop using plastic, it seems as if we would have to throw away everything and start over. Except that throwing everything away would create a lot of waste in our landfills. So the next best solution it would seem would be to start reducing the amount of plastic we produce and re-use as much as possible of the plastic that is already in our daily lives.
It Turns Out Our University Is Made Almost Entirely of Plastic
Plastics Challenge - Mindy Preston, Sect. 307 (TA: Tiffany Grade)
As an extremely stubborn person willing to do ridiculous things for the flimsiest of reasons, I was excited to see the description of the the Plastics Challenge. I immediately wrote up a list of things I'd have to do without, or try to substitute, on No Plastics Day:
- mechanical pencils
- pens
- elastic
- backpacks
- bicycles with brake cables or derailleurs. Bike helmets too, and lights, and fenders, and...
- raingear
- clothing with synthetic fabrics in it, including every pair of gloves I own
- shoes with plastic grommets or zippers or synthetic insoles
- plastic folders
- softcover books
- public soap and toilet paper dispensers
- pretty much all carpets
- many tables and chairs
- anything soft and cushy (almost all cushions are made from plastic foams)
- my refrigerator and oven
- anything electronic (printed circuit boards are made of plastic)
- wires, and anything that uses them (they have plastic insulators around them)
- my student ID, credit cards, drivers license, and other plastic identifiers
Preparation
With this list in mind, I took some preparatory measures for No Plastics Day. I went through all my clothing and found the least synthetic items I owned. I was able to find shirts and pants made entirely of cotton and wool. I have a pair of leather shoes that just had a pair of plastic shoelace ends, so I snipped those off and tied off the ends. I put some leftovers in a metal bowl, covered it with aluminum foil, and put them out on the porch to stay cool outside the refrigerator. I put some cardboard down over hardwood floor to substitute for my mattress, got another box to use as a pillow, and rounded up some old candles to use for illumination. I couldn't find a blanket that wasn't made of synthetic fabric, so I took the wool lining out of an old coat to use for a blanket. I took a cake of soap and put it in a cotton handkerchief, for hand-washing in places with plastic soap dispensers, and grabbed a roll of toilet paper to carry around. I got ready to walk around all day, rather than bike or take the bus.
I couldn't prepare away my need for a few items without spending money, which I wasn't willing to do. I don't own any all-natural undergarments, so I wore the least-synthetic of these I owned. I need to carry my cell phone because some members of my family are in delicate health, but I did not answer the phone for anyone other than family during No Plastics Day. I couldn't find gloves that didn't have a synthetic fabric lining, so I wore partly-plastic gloves all day rather than lose my hands to frostbite. The coat I wore is either 100% wool with metal accents or 100% scary polyester from the 1970s; I strongly suspect it's the former, but I can't prove it. (That coat also causes random strangers to yell "Hey, Sgt. Pepper!!!" at me, but that's probably not relevant to the Plastics Challenge.)
No Plastics Day
I started No Plastics Day at 8:00 on Sunday night by changing into my plastic-light clothes, lighting some candles, and trying to read a hardcover book. I couldn't get enough light from the candles, so instead I sat around in the dark, playing the bass and then playing Go by myself, waiting to get tired enough to go to sleep. (I also drank a lot of brandy, mostly because it was in a glass bottle. Hey, I'm of age, I can drink alone in the dark if I want.) Eventually I got tired enough to lie down, which cued the third worst night of sleep I have ever had. The floor was really cold, and cardboard is in no way an awesome substitute for a comfortable mattress. My cardboard-box-pillow seemed awesome at first, but it got pretty old after a couple of hours. I was excited when I woke up for the 3,237st time and saw that, finally, it was light out.
I started my day by brushing my teeth with my finger (plastic toothbrush, but my toothpaste comes in a metal tube), looking sadly at my plastic refrigerator, and going out for coffee. I bought everything with cash, but the barista used a plastic cash register to ring me up. While she was hitting buttons, I thought about what constitutes "use" of plastic. Is it cheating if someone else uses it for me? What about if I can't help using it? The lights in the shop were on; music was coming out of a plastic speaker. There's likely PVC plumbing somewhere in the line of water that leads from the water table to the espresso machine. Even if I'm sitting on a wooden stool at a wooden table, drinking coffee out of a ceramic mug and eating a fresh-made sandwich off a real plate, there's still a real sense in which I'm using plastic. Over the course of the day, I looked at a lot of plastic things that convey information; for example, clocks, billboards, and shop window displays. By looking at them, I'm definitely using them, but how can one abstain from that?
Once I went to class, it was even harder to avoid using plastic. My first lecture had wooden seats and tables, but the lecturer uses a projector and a sound system - all pure plastic. The walls are covered in foam noise suppressant. My second lecture had plastic seats and tables; I could have stood awkwardly for the whole power lecture, but instead I sat and balanced my notes on my lap. I spent the middle portion of my day at the Historical Society, which has very little plastic except for its carpets - of course I used them extensively, to wipe the snow and ice off my shoes. I spent a few hours reading there, safely away from most plastic in the renovated Reading Room.
I returned home at about 4:30, and immediately had to clean up some cat vomit. I threw it into a plastic-bag-lined plastic garbage can. I will fully admit that I didn't even think about doing anything else with it, despite having several more hours of No Plastic Day. It would be possible to get a metal trash can and some kind of non-plastic liner, but even if I did, my trash would eventually have to go into the City of Madison's plastic refuse bins for collection. In this case, substitution seems kind of pointless.
After eating my delicious porch-refrigerated leftovers, which I was very glad to see hadn't frozen, I headed back to campus for a club meeting. We met in a plastic-carpeted room with plastic chairs and plastic tables, plastic whiteboards on the walls and plastic whiteboard markers to match. Most people brought their plastic laptops. I had to sharpen my non-plastic pencil, and so I shaved some wood into the plastic-lined plastic garbage bin. Our meeting lasted until 8:00, at which point I was very happy to conclude No Plastics Day by walking over to College Library and checking my e-mail for the first time in a whole day.
I was able to take many steps to avoid plastic use in my own home, but once I ventured out into the broader world, I was done for. The University, especially, presented me plastic at every turn. I expect most corporate environments would be the same - when you're shopping for cost-effective furniture in huge quantities, plastic makes a lot of sense. Considering that most worrying effects are those of chronic exposure, though, seeing plastic everywhere is worrying indeed.